Wednesday, March 01, 2006

Iraq, Iran and the Draft... Places or People

I'm one of the first people to argue for a strong national defense and military. But, I'm noticing a trend. Maybe it is not really a new trend, but I hope others are noticing it too. I'd like to think the media is doing some investigative journalism to keep our government honest.

When we hear about bombings in Iraq, do we think of bombs exploding in some place in Iraq or do we think about people (mostly civilians) having their limbs ripped off or beyond recognition? Is it okay if we don't witness the gore? Is it justified because we're doing our part for their Democracy"? These are people like you and me - aren't they? Was their crime being born into the wrong country or nationality? When do we stop and sniff the napalm?

After all, in the past 30 years we have been both allies and enemies of the governments of Iran and Iraq often immersed in or facilitating friction with one or the other - at times both.

Is Iraq more democratic now that Shias and Sunnis settle old scores with more killings? Who among us don't harbor resentments and friction with certain work associates, neighbors and family members? Why do we think a document or military force will settle things, when clearly humankind is often not disposed to do so?

I spoke about my concern of the post invasion fumble and no exit strategy. We're already starting to hear the beat of anti-Iran rhetoric. Mind you, we're not really distinguishing between the place, government or people. Is this turmoil because our footprint is creating it? Are we legitimately bringing stability to the area? Which side of the gun muzzle are you facing?

Iraq's Shias are undeterred by borders. They might well seek Iranian assistance, but since we insist Iran (a place) is a pending nuclear threat we might have to stay in Iraq longer to keep stability in the region. Is this sounding at all familiar to anyone? Nuclear threat, threatening leadership, save their people to introduce our Democracy, drop bombs.

Okay, are you ready for the "what if"? What if we say Iran is a nuclear threat and this is W's justification for bombings. Are you prepared to send your sons and daughters to the war zone, because the Pentagon brass has already made it clear our over-extended combat troops (many of whom are National Guard and reservists) are near breaking?

We have insufficient numbers of combat troops to keep them replenished with volunteers. Ever wonder why $580 million was allocated to the draft board that has not instituted a draft in over 30 years? Or that high school kids' names, demographics and social security numbers are sent to the Department of Defense unless a parent knows they have an opt-out option?

If my military experience means anything, these draftees will be kids from less advantaged backgrounds and not eligible for multiple draft deferments like some who may not be serving so honorably.

Being Patriotic includes the responsibility of also questioning the judgment of those in charge who put our youth in harm's way. Blindly following so called "leaders" who have made no personal sacrifice themselves to further their own self-serving agendas is simply wrong.

I'm not willing to bet your life on it or that of your kids and grandkids. Are you?

1 Comments:

At 2:13 PM, Blogger sevenpointman said...

In the year before he succumb to cancer, Col. Hackworth. a gung-ho marine from the Nam era, was barred from the media, because he wanted to bring to our attention his feedback from those serving in Iraq.
He had asked those serving to send him e-mail's expressing their views about life on the ground in Iraq. He received numerous horror stories of endangering troops, poor logistical tactics, an environment made more and more insecure and dangerous, fear, enormous stress, and confusion about the reasons for serving. A full two-thirds of the service personel (in a sample of about 2000 e-mails from way back in late 2003 to mid 2004) wanted us out in less than a year.
This information, like hundred's of other stories that question the lunacy of this war, was suppressed by the corporate neo-con mass media.

If you and your friend and realtives want a more reasonable approach to this war-with a comprehensive exit strategy that will get us out safely, with honor, and will not lead to a civil war-go to my blog:sevenpointman

Don't just browse there.
Leave your comment.
Make copies and circulate my plan which has been approved by many activists and scholars including:
Bejamin Ferencz-Chief Prosecutor at the Nuremburg Trials, Tom Hayden, Tony Benn, Mattew
Rothschild, Reggie Rivers and Danny Schecter.

Most people want us out as soon as possible.
I have the way to do it.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home